Why is Hip-hop dead?

Euphanasia

Well-Known Member
#21
I've read arguments on both sides of this. I can understand what both Casey Rain and Illmatic are saying. I honestly don't know whether or not hip hop is dying, I just really hope it's not because hip hop is a huge part of my life. I don't want to live in a world without rap music. I don't want to ride around in my car with the windows down bumping Coldplay.

I can only hope that my favorite artists continue to make music. I can accept the fact that we won't see another Tupac Shakur, but I at least need to hear music from Nas, Jay, Em, Weezy, Kanye, Game, Buck, Lupe, Sheek, Obie, et cetera.

Maybe it is dying, maybe the industry is just in the middle of a great shift, i can't really say.
 

Chronic

Well-Known Member
#26
If it's dead it's because of the music industry, a fickle fanbase and rappers unwilling to break the existing format for whatever reason.

It's interesting that a lot of people who think it's dying only listen to household names.
 

hizzle?

Well-Known Member
Staff member
#27
Everyone said rock was dead in the early 90's.



Then Nirvana and the whole grunge scene came along.

The problem with rap is that it can't have different styles while Rock can...

Rock, in its distant family, has metal, grunge, punk, alternative, classic rock, psychadelic, etc...

Rap only evolved, it never created different styles of music. It went from old school to new school, keeping the same style, same genre of beats...

I do not consider West Coast, East Coast, Midwest, Dirty South as different rap styles, it all has the same basics...

i'll add to this later.
 

Preach

Well-Known Member
#28
If it's dead it's because of the music industry, a fickle fanbase and rappers unwilling to break the existing format for whatever reason.

It's interesting that a lot of people who think it's dying only listen to household names.
Brilliant point.

I also want to point out that Hip-Hop came, it saw, it conquered. Some genres existed and evolved before they became the prominent genre of mainstream music. Over the last decade, hiphop has had it's shine as the major mainstream genre with the most success. Now that it's toning down, everybody is talking about hiphop dying, but I don't think it is. It's just taking a step backwards and finding its identity as a self-contained genre that lives on regardless of the mainstream. Rock has been around since forever and what's changed? It's still about the guitar. Don't tell me rock has been reinvented a thousand times and hiphop hasn't because that's bullshit. Then in maybe another couple of decades, it'll make its return. Hiphop can only die when it's no longer current, and so long as things happen in the current, there will be rappers to talk about it. Rappers drop freestyle verses about recent events quite often, but I don't see a lot of rock tracks made on the spot in honor of something that aired on the news a couple of days ago. So in a sense, hiphop can be current in a way that other genres aren't. It's just what Chronic said about not trying to break format. On the other hand, I want to point out that people like Kanye REALLY broke format on his last record, and I rly didn't like it.
 

S O F I

Administrator
Staff member
#29
If it's dead it's because of the music industry, a fickle fanbase and rappers unwilling to break the existing format for whatever reason.

It's interesting that a lot of people who think it's dying only listen to household names.
It's equally interesting that a lot of people who think hip-hop is not dying are those who can't come up with the proper evidence to support their belief. It usually comes down to:

"You didn't listen to this mixtape that was posted on this and this blog by this and this artist?"

OR they list out the same rappers that most hip-hop fans BLAME for its presumed demise.

and I don't want to be misconstrued, I don't feel offended by your post and I'm not responding because I think it pertains to me because it doesn't, but it's something I've noticed on this board at least.


There are probably a lot of good reasons why people say it's dead and can provide evidence of it. I think Casey has the gist of it. I don't agree with the "brown planet" comments at all and I don't think hip-hop can't be revived. I don't think white kids listened to rap because they knew their parents hated Blacks or were scared of them, I think white kids listened to rap because they could identify with the rebellious tones within the songs.
 

hizzle?

Well-Known Member
Staff member
#30
I personally started listening to European rap... The principles and the values of their songs and the way they perceive hip-hop are the same as when hip hop started in the 80s in North America...
 

ill-matic

Well-Known Member
#34
You know what illy? I hate to be so brash, but you're just plain wrong.

It is dying. It is not happening. I know, because I talk to management, label heads, and people DEEP in this industry on a daily basis. You forget that I'm managed by one of the people directly responsible for discovering and building the success of Cypress Hill, The Fugees, Nas and many more, an absolutely pivotal figure in hip-hop, the man knows his shit, and when he tells me it's dying and tells me why, you cannot argue with those facts.
I forgot that your managed by who? Stop name dropping people to give your argument more credit. Everyone is entitled to their opinions. Nas, someone heavily involved in the game, claimed that hip hop was dead. Just because he's a credible rapper i have to believe every word he says? For every person that claims it's dead, there's always someone who will claim the opposite. Nas said it was dead, 90% of other rappers claimed it was alive. So who do i believe?

How about i form my OWN opinion based on what i'm hearing and what i can observe, instead of bowing down to "some guy in the industry" as if his opinion and perspective is the be all and end all.

Casey Rain said:
Labels are not even signing hip-hop artists. They are dropping the hip-hop artists they do have. Everyone from the smallest label to the biggest. Even Dr. Dre let go of almost everyone at Aftermath save for his two big-hitters, Eminem and 50. They won't put money into it, and they won't market it properly, because it's not worth their money for the amount of return they get on it. I'd be willing to bet that hip-hop fans illegally download more than any other genre of music. TV shows won't book hip-hop artists any more. Radio stations don't want to play the music.
I beg to differ. When it comes to acts like Souljah Boy etc, there is a risk being taken when you throw money at them in signing them and marketing their music. This clearly shows that they are still willing to take those risks with new acts.

What are you basing this off anyway? Because from the looks of things, and the amount of hip hop music out there, it clearly contradicts your point.

Casey Rain said:
And it's not about them 'using the internet' to get out there. Sure, that helps a little bit, but like I said to salty, it really only helps to the people that actively search for the music, and that isn't the way it should be.
And how did they do it in the late 80s and early 90s? All i'm saying is that it's easier to get your music heard now than it ever has been.


Casey Rain said:
Elvis was not an innovator, he was a thief. The Beatles were very much innovators, but they had the backing and full financial support of one of the biggest record labels in the world, and the genre was still new and fresh. Do you think The Beatles could have broken out if rock n roll wasn't supported by the TV and the radio? Not to mention (and this goes back to my earlier point), parents were scared of rock n roll at that time. It was rebellious for the kids to listen to it, so it sold. The rebellion factor lead to it spreading via word of mouth as well as traditional marketing means. That simply isn't the case with hip-hop in 2009, it's not rebellious, it's not supported by the media anymore, and as far as the internet goes, yes you can market yourself well, but how many people are buying your album and how many people are spreading the word COMPARED to the amount of people that download it off a torrent, listen to it a couple of times max, and then forget all about it?
Why does hip hop have to always be steeped in some sort of controversy or be black listed as "rebellious music" for it to have ongoing success? Rock isn't nearly as "rebellious" as it was with the emergence of the 60s, yet its popularity is unparalleled, and there is still music of a high quality still being produced.

Clearly with the emergence of artists like Kanye and Lupe etc (who actually do get a fair degree of radio play, and who are quite popular), shows that hip hop doesn't have to be cornered as "rebellious music" anymore. It doesn't JUST have to be something which kids listen to to piss their parents off. Kanye is a perfect example of hip hop moving away from that "rebellious" jibe, and still maintaining a high degree of popularity.

And as far as i can see, hip hop IS supported by the media. how is it not? when was it supported more by the media than it is now? are you insane man? there's WAYYY more channels dedicated to hip hop on the radio and on television than at any time in hip hop's history. i have no idea where you got this from?

Casey Rain said:
See above. This is a moot point. I didn't get it all wrong, you're talking to someone that lives this shit daily. I run my own Internet marketing company for artists, I look after a bunch of people including a girl that Timbaland recently signed, so don't assume I don't know what I'm talking about here.
Never missing an opportunity to big note yourself :)

Casey Rain said:
Oh - and Lily Allen and Arctic Monkeys WERE NOT discovered by MySpace. That was a big marketing ploy, and a lie. Evidently it worked since you believed it. Lily Allen is bankrolled by her famous actor father and a couple of guys she was fucking that produced her first few tracks...clearly that wasn't as good of a story as 'look at me I was discovered on MySpace'.....Arctic Monkeys had good timing, claiming to have been found on MySpace at a time when MySpace was all over the news. Where are they now?

Oh, and I know people that work at MySpace, if you're wondering how I knew that it was all bullshit, I knew from the start.
Of COURSE you know people that work at MySpace. There's some more name dropping. Yes, you know more than anyone else because of this and that. Listen homie, i also know people in the record industry, but that doesn't mean shit. and i'm not going to use "who i know" or whatever to make myself sound more credible. sheesh.


Casey Rain said:
You completely missed my point. Back at the peak of hip-hop in the mid 90's, there was an artistic balance between socio-political/gangsta and pop oriented club music. People like 'Pac and Snoop would recieve heavy club play, because the climate at the time allowed for music that was danceable but also spoke about real issues, real topics.

The world is a much darker place now, and as a result people look for escapism, an alternate reality, through music. Of course, this is not a new phenemenon, and I am not 'blaming' the death of hip-hop on this.....I am simply pointing it out as a contributing factor.
The only tracks by Pac and Snoop that were played in the clubs were about drinking alcohol, and fucking bitches. Not much has changed...

And as an illustration of the fickleness of fans;

* Can't Touch This - MC Hammer
* Ice Ice Baby - Vanilla Ice
* Jump - Kriss Kross
* Good Vibrations - Marky Mark and the Funky Bunch


Just to name a few. Sure, I agree, music in my opinion was better back then. But that is subjective. Someone may say that music is better now. It's an opinion.

And furthermore, as you said, people in this climate aren't really wanting to hear politically charged music and all that shit. Especially not in these times where they can get all that crap from the news. Hence why Nas' last album was considered crap. But that doesn't mean hip hop is dying.


The world is changing, the industry is changing and hip hop is changing with it. The fact is, people love to romanticise the past, and get all sentimental and nostalgic with how things were. They fail to embrace the changes and the evolution of the genre. Whenever it deviates from how it was back in the "golden era" people get scared, and start prophesising that it's all doom and gloom and coming to an end, rather than accepting that YES, it is different, but that doesn't mean it's run is coming to an end. Just because people fail to accept the changes, and end up resenting what new up and comers are doing (ala Lil Wayne etc), they immediately yell that hip hop is dying.

Get a grip people. It's not dying.
 

ill-matic

Well-Known Member
#35
Following your logic - what is hip-hop in Lil Wayne's music? He barely even raps. There's nothing from the original hip-hop culture in his music, at least I fail to see it.
The FANS listen to what they like and I understand that it's hard to like his "music". It's not "A little" different, do you really not see it? He totally destroys hip-hop's image.

Back to the original thread somebody asked about good 07,08 albums.
Wasn't the 5 percent album finally released in 2007? And it contained some of the dopest past 2005 tracks.

I still love this track:
[YOUTUBE]E7xmhqvHAfY[/YOUTUBE]
As soon as someone deviates just a little bit from the usual formula of hip hop, it's considered "not hip hop". Why does everything have to be pooled into one gigantic thing? Rock as Grunge, Alternate, Soft, Thrash metal, Death Metal, bla bla bla. the list goes on.

Why can't we embrace this as a new form of hip hop? A different type of hip hop? Why can't we let the music evolve and let it work itself out, instead of being so dismissive about it?

This attitude is NOT good for the music.

Hip hop fans are too snobby when it comes to music. I'm tired of hearing:

"Man what you hear on the radio is not hip hop. You have to listen to Common, Nas and El-P ; they ARE hip hop. That's what hip hop is about man!! Not this Lil Wayne, 50 Cent shit!!"
 

Preach

Well-Known Member
#36
sorry, too long post.

(been waiting for this :D)

i'll add that i'm sorta elitist about music, but uh.. how do i explain this. i can dismiss music for the most superficial of reasons. i bet i'll start liking kanye's album in a year or so, when something new hits that to me is a new low. but the difference is i don't claim hiphop is dead, and i can very much appreciate mainstream music.
 

masta247

Well-Known Member
Staff member
#38
As soon as someone deviates just a little bit from the usual formula of hip hop, it's considered "not hip hop". Why does everything have to be pooled into one gigantic thing? Rock as Grunge, Alternate, Soft, Thrash metal, Death Metal, bla bla bla. the list goes on.

Why can't we embrace this as a new form of hip hop? A different type of hip hop? Why can't we let the music evolve and let it work itself out, instead of being so dismissive about it?
Because the music that calls itself hip-hop in many cases is more similar to pop than to hip-hop. If g-unit or lil wayne say that they are true hip-hop they are fooling other people.
I'd gladly accept a new genre "hip-pop" or something if they stayed away from the real deal.

This attitude is NOT good for the music.
I still enjoy hip-hop and my attitude is positive, I still support my favorite artists and those that I find good. I just can't be positive towards what I see on tv now. I don't think that this attitude is bad. I feel that what I'm doing is actually good for hip-hop. I don't want people to mix up "my" music with "bling and titties".

Hip hop fans are too snobby when it comes to music. I'm tired of hearing:

"Man what you hear on the radio is not hip hop. You have to listen to Common, Nas and El-P ; they ARE hip hop. That's what hip hop is about man!! Not this Lil Wayne, 50 Cent shit!!"
Then we differ here. When I hear something like this I feel like there are still people that feel the "real" hip-hop and know what's good and their taste is similar to mine. I guess that because of them I still can listen to good music. They go and buy albums of artists that I listen to so anyone in my position would be glad.
 

Casey

Well-Known Member
Staff member
#39
What are you basing this off anyway?

i have no idea where you got this from?
You are right. You don't know where I'm getting this from or what I'm basing it off. You don't work in this industry on a DAILY basis. I do. That's the difference, and believe me, it's a big one.

Give it a year and you'll see that I'm right. I'd put money on it. You'll probably be able to count the amount of truly great hip-hop albums that come out in 2009 on ONE hand. That's already the case for the last three years at least.

Compare that with the amount of great hip-hop albums that came out every year from 1994 onwards, and you honestly think it's not dying?

I could give a shit about people you might know in the industry, the fact is that YOU are not in it.

I know a bunch of professional chefs, does that mean I know anything about cooking?

I'll say it once more in case you didn't hear me.

On a day-to-day basis I have conversations with artists, radio DJ's, music producers, artists management, entertainment lawyers, TV hosts, people who run music sites and blogs, and people so deep in this game that you wouldn't even begin to understand. Do you think you know better than ALL those people, most of which have been doing this their whole lives?

Never mind me, you prove your OWN arrogance by making the assumption that I'm namedropping (when I never mentioned a single person's ACTUAL name), solely to prove my point. That's not the case at all.

You mention Kanye, who DELIBERATELY steered clear of hip-hop to maintain his radio play. If he had made another album like his first three, it wouldn't have sold. The climate is different now. G-Unit learned that. They sold millions with their debut and yet their second album barely pushed a couple hundred thousand units. Nothing had changed in what they were doing, so where do you think the change was?

808's and Heartbreak is not a hip-hop album, it's a pop album. There's barely any rapping on it, they are putting Rihanna on a new version of the next single to sell more records. As for Lupe, I don't remember the last time I heard him on the radio. 'Superstar' maybe? That was damn near a year ago, homie.

Labels are not putting a cent into hip-hop music any more. Do you know any A&R's? I do. Ask them who was the last hip-hop act they signed that hasn't been dropped yet. The 'new' hip-hop artists that are coming out in some degree (People like Kid Cudi and Asher Roth) have had their deals for 2+ years.


Of COURSE you know people that work at MySpace. There's some more name dropping. Yes, you know more than anyone else because of this and that. Listen homie, i also know people in the record industry, but that doesn't mean shit. and i'm not going to use "who i know" or whatever to make myself sound more credible.
You are missing the point again. I didn't mention it for credibility. I mention it because it's the TRUTH. You tried to claim Lily Allen and Arctic Monkeys were 'discovered' by MySpace when I know for a -------> FACT <-------- that that is complete and utter PR bullshit.

So don't give me this 'internet makes it easier for artists to get discovered' bullshit.

If anything it makes it harder because A&R's looking for talented artists have to wade through much more bullshit by morons sitting in his bedrooms attempting to rap over 50 Cent instrumentals and uploading them to their shitty MySpace page.

The amount of demo's I (just as an artist) get given by wannabe's who see me on stage and think that I'm in a position to give them a shot, is testament to that. Let me tell how many of them are half decent. Next to fucking none. I can't imagine the bullshit that radio DJ's and A&R's have to wade through. They don't have time for it, so they stick with tried-and-tested material that has run it's course.
 

Chronic

Well-Known Member
#40
It's equally interesting that a lot of people who think hip-hop is not dying are those who can't come up with the proper evidence to support their belief.
I actually meant something else. I'll use an analogy.

It's like an American who can't even point his own country out on a map and doesn't know anything about other countries saying "America is the best country in the world!". Doesn't matter whether or not he's right, it's just that he can't know.

I don't really have an opinion on Hip-Hop being dead. I don't know what exactly that means. It's dead sales wise? The frequency of quality albums is dropping and will continue to drop? Is it an elitist thing, like saying Lil Wayne isn't Hip-Hop?
 

Latest posts

Donate

Any donations will be used to help pay for the site costs, and anything donated above will be donated to C-Dub's son on behalf of this community.

Members online

No members online now.
Top