Tragedy Khadafi is one of the greatest rappers of all time. Discuss.
- Thread starter Casey
- Start date
I think he means that the people who should know know who he is. Meaning a New York head would know him but probably not some random person or rap fan.
To me Kadafi was definitely talented but most of his verses sound like an artist in training (which is what the OUTLAWZ were I guess), his flow was sometimes sloppy and rushed, just like some of his writing. Sometimes he showed a lot of potential but that's it. He died before we could see just how good he was so he might have been better than Tragedy eventually but we'll never know.
It's kind of hard to compare the two though. Kadafi was never out there as an actual artist, he just made some guest appearances or worked with a group. Making actual songs is a lot harder than just having to write a verse for an existing concept. Tragedy proved himself as an artist even before Pac truly blew up, Kadafi only proved himself to be a favorite OUTLAW among Pac fans. And of course there are always the rumors that Pac helped the LAWZ with their verses at times.
To me Kadafi was definitely talented but most of his verses sound like an artist in training (which is what the OUTLAWZ were I guess), his flow was sometimes sloppy and rushed, just like some of his writing. Sometimes he showed a lot of potential but that's it. He died before we could see just how good he was so he might have been better than Tragedy eventually but we'll never know.
It's kind of hard to compare the two though. Kadafi was never out there as an actual artist, he just made some guest appearances or worked with a group. Making actual songs is a lot harder than just having to write a verse for an existing concept. Tragedy proved himself as an artist even before Pac truly blew up, Kadafi only proved himself to be a favorite OUTLAW among Pac fans. And of course there are always the rumors that Pac helped the LAWZ with their verses at times.
GTFOH!!!:laugh:
And as far as popularity goes, both of them are probably equally unpopular to the average listener, but Trag is def more respected amongst the hip-hop legends. Being a member of the Juice Crew and reppin QB with underground classics for years holds more weight than a few verses as Pac's sidekick
btw Trag's verse on "T.O.N.Y.">>> any Outlaw verse
And as far as popularity goes, both of them are probably equally unpopular to the average listener, but Trag is def more respected amongst the hip-hop legends. Being a member of the Juice Crew and reppin QB with underground classics for years holds more weight than a few verses as Pac's sidekick
btw Trag's verse on "T.O.N.Y.">>> any Outlaw verse
i enjoy yaki more than tragedy, but that's because i really like yaki, and i never really got the time to get into tragedy.
either way, measuring one rapper up against another is like measuring one's personality up against someone else's and saying who's is the better person. we all come from different backgrounds, experienced different things, <insert n00b highroad speech here> point being that it's not really fair to say one rapper is better than the other. it's like saying a curling iron is better than a pair of red socks. it may or may not be true but it's an unrealistic comparison to make altogether.
tragedy's voice, flow and lyrics have little in common with yaki's to me, but like i said, it's not like i'm a tragedy khadafi expert.
either way, measuring one rapper up against another is like measuring one's personality up against someone else's and saying who's is the better person. we all come from different backgrounds, experienced different things, <insert n00b highroad speech here> point being that it's not really fair to say one rapper is better than the other. it's like saying a curling iron is better than a pair of red socks. it may or may not be true but it's an unrealistic comparison to make altogether.
tragedy's voice, flow and lyrics have little in common with yaki's to me, but like i said, it's not like i'm a tragedy khadafi expert.
And I haven't seen or heard anybody talk about Tragedy Khadafi and his work period. Does that mean, he can't have any instant classics because of that. Because that's what your saying according to your arguent.
And of course, it could be possible that Yak won't make top 500 because he never had the chance to do any solo efforts as has been pointed out in this thread in previous posts. But what's Tragedy's excuse. A man who's been in the game for more than a decade. No matter what, Khadafi can outrap Tragedy no matter how many ways you or anybody else wants to put it. That's my word and I'm sticking to it. Now if you and these other people could stop making these comparisons to the Outlaws maybe we could move on.
And of course, it could be possible that Yak won't make top 500 because he never had the chance to do any solo efforts as has been pointed out in this thread in previous posts. But what's Tragedy's excuse. A man who's been in the game for more than a decade. No matter what, Khadafi can outrap Tragedy no matter how many ways you or anybody else wants to put it. That's my word and I'm sticking to it. Now if you and these other people could stop making these comparisons to the Outlaws maybe we could move on.
I don't wanna sound like a dick, but you won't win this argument Bombsquad. You won't see me say this much, but this here is BARELY EVEN DEBATABLE. Dude can't see Tragedy and that's that. It's not even that he's an absolutely incredible rapper, he's just better in many ways. Whether it be as a rapper overall or material.
:laugh: @ winning. Unless I'm winning some money or a trophy, I could careless about being victorious in a hip hop debate. I just think it's ridiculous that cats are saying that Tragedy is better than Khadafi LYRICALLY. If you want to argue about MUSICALLY, then say that SPECIFICALLY instead of the >> stuff.
This whole debate started with someone saying that Tragedy is ten times better than Khadafi in the Outlawz. I replied saying that lyrically Khadafi of the Outlawz will eat Tragedy in any day and age of his career. I compared the two based on lyrical because that's all you can judge them based on seeing as you can't compare them both on solo efforts.
Sure Kadafi had more potential to be even better than what he was. But the status he reached imo is far greater than what Tragedy has achieved today and what he is as a whole. Overall Yak is better than Tragedy. Yaki has a better voice, better flow, was flexible, made good appearances, involved in classic material, better lyricists. That's what I've got to say for now.
This whole debate started with someone saying that Tragedy is ten times better than Khadafi in the Outlawz. I replied saying that lyrically Khadafi of the Outlawz will eat Tragedy in any day and age of his career. I compared the two based on lyrical because that's all you can judge them based on seeing as you can't compare them both on solo efforts.
Sure Kadafi had more potential to be even better than what he was. But the status he reached imo is far greater than what Tragedy has achieved today and what he is as a whole. Overall Yak is better than Tragedy. Yaki has a better voice, better flow, was flexible, made good appearances, involved in classic material, better lyricists. That's what I've got to say for now.
fuck man, somebody please close this fuckin thread... if dude likes yak more then fuck, whatever who gives a shit. Everybody has their own taste. I honestly say when measuring skills tragedy has alot more than yak. But if theres ppl out there that feel him more, than good for them. This is turning into an Israel vs Palestine debate, like theres no convincing the other side. And c'mon who really cares who's the more popular emcee... Theres ppl that would argue that 50 cent is a better emcee than some1 like Chino XL, and giving the 'popularity' factor any sort of weight would make that a valid arguement. When we all know that that's total bullshit. So lets all get on with our lives instead of argueing about 2 artists who have nothing in common other than similar names.
really.
I challenge Bombsquad to make a poll on a non-Pac forum, just a general hip-hop forum such as sohh.com, allhiphop.com, xclusivesoundstation.com....and the results will be so heavily lopsided he'll have no choice but to say "I'm wrong"
LOL
nothing wrong with a lil debate btw. Aint like nobody has resorted to name calling and threats becuz of this thread
I challenge Bombsquad to make a poll on a non-Pac forum, just a general hip-hop forum such as sohh.com, allhiphop.com, xclusivesoundstation.com....and the results will be so heavily lopsided he'll have no choice but to say "I'm wrong"
LOL
nothing wrong with a lil debate btw. Aint like nobody has resorted to name calling and threats becuz of this thread
Ay fuck you asshole, i'll kill you're mother.
haha i'm kidding, you're right though.
I love when people on a HIP HOP forum are like "who cares who best, why should we debate about that?"
BECAUSE ITS A FUCKING HIP HOP FORUM, what else is it for?
But, Tragedy all around is a better emcee then Yak.
Yak was decent though.
haha i'm kidding, you're right though.
I love when people on a HIP HOP forum are like "who cares who best, why should we debate about that?"
BECAUSE ITS A FUCKING HIP HOP FORUM, what else is it for?
But, Tragedy all around is a better emcee then Yak.
Yak was decent though.
Donate
Any donations will be used to help pay for the site costs, and anything donated above will be donated to C-Dub's son on behalf of this community.
Members online
No members online now.