I feel like you grew up in 1902 and are trying to impose your views onto 2011. Everytime something new comes out, whether it be music, movies, or games, you have everything negative to say, and nothing positive
I do like Dragon Age series. I liked the first game and yes, I have mixed feelings about the latter one.
I listen to a lot of new music and watch a lot of new movies. Actually I think that the last few years were great for music, especially hip-hop despite the fact that most people bitch about how hip-hop is dead. I rarely find opportunities to discuss that music here as most people here don't really dig further into hip-hop anymore. I complain about music/artists that I find low, yes. And it often bothers me when people are satisfied with less. Instead of criticizing people for picking them I criticize these choices, maybe that's why I give a negative impression.
If it comes to me being bitter about movies - I don't really recall. Perhaps the movies and music that I see discussed are just low to me if you see me criticizing them. Also it might be that I like something yet I don't bother saying "ooh awesome" but instead, I point out what I don't like about it.
As far as I know, most people who play games are noobs, rendering their opinions worthless, which is why I don't listen to them. I fail to see how they've dumbed dragon age down, if they're giving your character a voice what do you expect them to do? Have a topic sentence or a paragraph for each option? Figure it out. And again as for dumbing game play down? How could they do that? Dragon age 1 was dumbe down to the max.
I think that most noobs playing games don't go to their dedicated forums and make thousands of posts. I think that internet forums and gaming websites (at least those that I visit) are dominated by people who are die-hard fans and know everything about that game. These people criticize DA2 the most btw.
Again, refer to my comment on what happens when you give the character a voice. I don't understand why you feel it is dumbed down. You have to be as dumb as a sack of bricks to not realise whether you were picking the bully option, the good guy option, the flirt option etc. in the first dragon age. How is it any different having a little symbol there? Again, the dialogue of OTHER characters was amazing in dragon age 1, your characters dialogue however, was piss poor, because, oh I don't know? Wait i do, THERE WAS NONE.
Did you play that demo after all? DA2 has dialogues which you can actually just skip by choosing the same option without even reading what it says - that's the problem. Actually reading it wouldn't change anything as it's often something else than what your character actually says, so you have to pick an option to find out what it really means.
In Dragon Age 1 you had to actually read what you're about to say and you knew what you are going to say. What you did not know was the real outcome. There was no "bully", "do-gooder" "pick-this-if-you-don't-want-any-bad-outcome" option like it is in DA2. Many dialogues had fascinating, unpredictable outcomes and there were rarely extreme options. Usually it was something in between and sometimes you actually had to think for a second about which dialogue option to pick, sometimes you had to be careful as every character in the game was different and could react differently to whatever you were going to say.
I think that dialogues in Dragon Age 1 were very good. It was one of my favorite elements of that game, something that really hooked me to it because before that, frankly I didn't like fantasy RPG games at all.
DA2 spoils that all by introducing a "click here for good/bad/neutral outcome" option. It's literally that bad.
Dialogues feel more like watching an interactive movie. Now I love Mass Effect but I was amongst those who couldn't understand why Bioware decided to use the conversation wheel. In DA2 in my option it's even worse.
I can clearly see this game being aimed at people who don't really want to read dialogues, those who just want a "spectacular" fight.
At all times the game makes that clear - by changing the dialogue system, fighting system, story etc.
That's why I think that this game is dumbed down and that's why I'm criticizing it. It seems way less ambitious, feels like they took away what I enjoyed about Dragon Age the most to make it appeal to a wider audience.