Minardi said:
i just wonder how you can be born as a bad person, when when at the same time they say you either go to haven or hell for eternity...
who is born a bad person? According to Islam every child is born sinless, and no sin is inherited. Islam does not recognize any original sin whatsoever, no man would have to be born with it. every child born is a pure innocent creature, which will only become sinful when it actually commits a sin itself, and one definitely cannot commit a sin before one is born
if someone dies young in christian belief then they do go to heaven but tha age is around 10 and younger maybe and in my belief everyone is born with sin
are you sure? isnt everyone according to christianity born with the sin of adam and Eve's disobedience to God is passed on to their descendants and thus the whole of mankind is accursed with that Original Sin, from which no salvation is possible unless one believes in the atoning death on the cross of the Son of God.? how can a child who died at birth believe that hwne he she never had the chance to?
Illuminattile said:
So why doesn't God make it clear which religion is "right" and which is not? How can you worship a God who would punish perfectly kind and benevolent people just because they were taught the wrong religion?
for example? even if he did it make it clear to you, you still wouldnt believe it unless he himself appeared infront of you and told you which one is right and which is wrong, you must understand religion before you ask such questions, there would be no purpose in life if he did just that, i believe he has pointed to us which religion is right and it is up to us to use our abilities which god gave us to find out which one it is
islamic point of view
ever since life began God has been sending His messengers or pophets to guide them along the “right path”. When prophets passed away, people who followed them differed among themselves in the understanding and interpretation of the Guidance they had received from God through those prophets. Sometimes, the wicked and selfish among them, deliberately distorted the true message out of their mutual ill will or to satisfy their greed.
Thus, it was that way new religions took place. Still, God sent prophets again to call people back to the original pure religion Nevertheless, these prophets were often treated with contempt and derision by their people. But God kept sending His prophets to teach people the “true religion”, as it was constantly being replaced by the innovations of mankind.
Later, when human culture and civilization came of age, and the new era of printing and communication was at its dawn, God sent His last prophet, Muhammad (pbuh) to fulfill what the earlier prophets had been teaching. He was given the Holy Qur'an, the final Book of revelation, which God promised to safeguard from all change or corruption. This was Islam (submission to the one and only God). In fact the Religion taught by all the prophets Jesus, Abraham, moses, Noah (pbut) though later their followers attributed their religions to the names of the prophets or so-called founders of those religions. Some even made such attributions to the names of the land where those prophets lived. Thus it was that Buddhism, Hinduism, Confucianism, Judaism and Christianity were born.
CalcuoCuchicheo said:
'Trials' and 'tests of faith' are nothing but control mechanisms and I put this to you;
Who would your God rather allow into Heaven
a) He who lives morally because he believes in God and fears punishment
b) He who lives morally because he believes in equality, justice and love
can you not believe in both a and b? at least i do
And I would recommend you actually sit down and think about what you believe in and why you believe in it. A never-ending life of bliss and perpetual happiness after you die? Doesn't that seem a bit too good to be true?
everything which has a beginning has a cause, it is self-evident that things that begin have a cause, no one really denies it in his heart. All science and history would collapse if this law of cause and effect were denied. my life had a beginning and i really dont believe that im livin my life for nothing, whats the point than?