Illmatic vs. Stillmatic

[SiGh]

Which album is better?
Discuss.

I personally like Stillmatic a lot better.

 

[roaches]

...Why?

 

[ARon]

^lol.

It's not like Stillmatic is bad, a lot of people including myself consider it a classic but come on. Illmatic is the best album ever made.

 

[tHuG $TyLe]

Illmatic. Though Stillmatic is still dope

 

[The.Menace]

Illmatic.

 

[Rukas]

Illmatic is the best album ever made.

Best Nas album you mean.

 

[Bobby Sands]

Illmatic all the way.Stillmatic is a good album too but there are some tracks i never listen to.I can just throw Illmatic on and listen to it right through without skipping anything.Its such a great album.

SiGh,you said you choose Stillmatic but it hasnt got any votes.Did you forget?

 

[SiGh]

^lol yes.

I dunno, I personally like Stillmatic more, tho it has been years since I last heard illmatic.

 

[Casey]

Illmatic. I do love Stillmatic though. Got it the day it dropped and then a week later they pulled all of them and re-released it without the track with Mary J Blige on. She apparently didnt want it to be on there.

 

[SiGh]

lol, im embarassed i made this thread, i think ima delete it so no one knows i was the only one that chose stillmatic.

 

[Bobby Sands]

What was the song with Mary J Blige?

 

[DPG iz all I C]

What was the song with Mary J Blige?

Braveheart Party

Illmatic>Stillmatic all the time.

 

[linx]

Illmatic is just ridiculous. An album shouldn't be allowed to be that good. Seriously.

 

[Farzin]

lol, im embarassed i made this thread, i think ima delete it so no one knows i was the only one that chose stillmatic.

That's because you must be deaf or slapped around a lot as a kid and now need a hearing aid.

Illmatic shits on Stillmatic and Stillmatic is a great album.

Illmatic has no fillers which makes that album so great.

 

[tHuG $TyLe]

Braveheart Party

Illmatic>Stillmatic all the time.

That song was terrible.

 

[ARon]

Best Nas album you mean.

No best album. There might be more important albums, Paid In Full for example, but nothing is as good as Illmatic. I'm not the only one who thinks so.

 

[PuffnScruff]

i love them both but i kind of agree with aristotle. this is one of the best hip hop albums to ever come out and could very well be the best hip hop album of all time. it was automatically ill and is an all time classic.

but i am biased as nas is my favorite rapper

 

[Telekinesiz]

I don't know the exactly reason, but i don't like Illmatic that much, but i know that's a flawless album, in the strictly sense of the word. So, my vote goes to Stillmatic, second print. (Braveheart Party was awful and i always thought they remove the song because of this LOL!)

 

[BIG NASTY]

Illmatic is the best album ever made.

No it is not.

 

[Cooper]

No best album. There might be more important albums, Paid In Full for example, but nothing is as good as Illmatic. I'm not the only one who thinks so.

It's not even the best rap album, nevermind the best album. It may well be the best Nas album tho.