Hip Hop is Dead a Classic?

#1
Nas :: Hip Hop is Dead
Def Jam
Author: Steve 'Flash' Juon


"Redhead Kingpin, Tim Dog, have you seen 'em?
Kwame, King Tee or King Sun
Super Lover Cee, Casanova Rud
Antoinette, Rob Base never showin up
You see Black Sheep, Group Home, Busy Bee?
Ask Ill and Al Skratch, +Where My Homiiies?+
Leave it to y'all, these niggaz left for dead
Last week my man swore he saw Special Ed
Rap is like a ghost town, real mystic
Like these folks never existed
They the reason that rap became addictive
Play they CD or wax and get lifted
I recommend when your kid turn ten
Let him hear Spice 1, made plenty noise
... Positive K, Father MC, the Skinny Boys
Where are they now?"

Good question. While Nas is making a list, I'd like updates on MC Lyte and MC Ren, Def Jef and Daddy-O, Kam and Threat. There's a lot of rappers in the industry who have simply dropped off the radar without leaving a trace or even a forwarding address. When Nas says "Hip Hop is Dead," he might as well be talking about the careers of the peers he namechecks in "Where Are They Now." It's a sad statement on today's generation that the legends of the golden age are nowhere to be found - they pop up on a single once in a blue moon or cameo on a compilation, and you're lucky if you hear about either. Artists from Kurtis Blow to Big Daddy Kane to Roxanne Shante ought to be lecturing to today's generation of rappers, passing on the lessons learned and the torch earned, but their voices are silent and hip-hop is forced to exist forever in the now - disconnected from the past and crippled in the future, left scarred emotionally like a child that grows up without parental role models.

It's a peculiar dichotomy that Nas declares hip-hop dead on his newest CD yet seems to be breathing new life into it at the same time. This is a reflective and thoughtful Nasir Jones, a Nas who looked at the Cristal bottle and left it on the shelf, a Nas who took off his bling chain for the day and put it away. If anybody has earned the right to floss his legitimately acquired wealth it would be Nas, who is far from an overnight sensation in hip-hop and has been putting his voice on wax for over 15 years. The man who helped usher in an era of extravagance as Nas Escobar knows there's more to life than the accumulation of wealth though, and it's an irony of history that the image sticks despite his continued insistance on releasing well thought out and carefully crafted albums. While some rhyme writers would have trouble making a 9 and up on their best day, Nas does it time and again on releases like "Stillmatic" and "Street's Disciple." How can you top a track record like that? Nobody can, not even Nas. He's not out to top himself on "Hip Hop is Dead," nor is he even proclaiming himself the savior of a dying artform. Incredibly it's all so much simpler than that.

"Nas is the ghetto American Idol
No matter what you do you're never gettin my title
I can't sound smart cause y'all will run away
They say I ain't hungry no more and I don't talk about yay
Like there's no other way for an ex-hustler
Cake getter, ex-wigsplitter to touch ya; I beg to differ
When you four years in the game, we can have a conversation
Eight years in the game, I invite you on vacation
Ten years in the game, after I've enjoyed my fame
Only then I'll let you pick my brain"

"Let There Be Light" indeed. The beat by Kanye West and hook by Tre Williams may set the tone, but it's Nas who makes the track all his own with this declaration - I'm the fucking man, case closed. If hip-hop isn't braggadocious, what is it? Going back to conception, coming up in stunted growth spurts, fumbling and reaching towards maturity with one step forward and occasionally two back, the one thing hip-hop has always been all along is cocky and self-assured, ever since the bang bang boogey up jumped the boogey to the rhythm of a boogedy beat. What you hear is not a test, Nas is rapping to the beat. His swagger and self-confidence on this CD are as old and proven as hip-hop itself, and the greatest thing about that kind of belief in yourself is there's no limit to the great achievements you can reach. Did Michael Jordan ever doubt he'd make the last second jump shot? Does Tiger Woods ever think he's going to miss the green on the 18th? They are great because they expect to be, and know deep down in their heart and soul success is destiny and failure is not an option. Tell 'em Nas - tell us why we "Can't Forget About You":

"So I will light a cigar in the corridor of the crib
Pictures on the wall of all the things that I did
All the money and fame, 8 by 10's
of the whole Rat Pack inside of a big frame
Collidin with big names that could've made your career stop
All that, and your man is still here and I'm still hot
Wow, I need a moment y'all
See I almost felt a tear drop
When was the last time you heard a real anthem
Nas, the millionaire, the mansion
When was the last time you heard your boy Nas rhyme
Never on schedule, but always on time
[...]
Can't forget about the old school, Bam, Cas, Melle Mel, Flash
Rocksteady spinnin on they back
Can't forget when the first rap Grammy went to Jazzy, Fresh Prince
Fat Boys broke up, rap hasn't been the same since
So irregular, how it messed you up
when Mr. T became a wrestler
Can't forget about Jordan's retirement
The shot Robert Horry to win the game in the finals kid
Some things are forever, some things are not
It's the things we remember that gave the world shock
They stay in a place in your mind so snug
Like who the person was with whom you first make love"

And there it is - Will.I.Am can produce it, Chrisette Michele can sing on it, but only the seemingly effortless flow Nas displays and how tightly spun his wordplay is can weave it into the tapestry of music that like the Nat King Cole track that inspires this song is truly "Unforgettable." At the darkest hour, when hip-hop had seemingly been abandoned to commercialism and cultural rape, Nas came back to say FUCK ALL THAT SHIT, WATCH HOW I DO IT AND LEARN SOMETHIN'. Far from hip-hop being dead, Nas has proven on this CD that it's alive and well. It's bizarre to even single out individual tracks on this album because every one is a masterpiece in its own right. The pounding L.E.S. and Wyldfyer opener "Money Over Bullshit" mixes old school scratches with modern day Queensbridge intensity that's undeniable, and it's only the first stop on a long road where every turn raises your expectations and then meets them. When Nas boldly states "You Can't Kill Me" he's speaking for himself AND the culture, and when he vows to "Carry on Tradition" he makes it clear that as long as he's alive, hip-hop's never dead and never could be.

The guests add on but never take away the focus from Nas. Jigga shares an epic beat with him on "Black Republican" but can't outshine him, Kanye West is "Still Dreaming" but Nas has an even bigger dream of success than he does, and even Snoop Dogg and The Game find that to "Play On Playa" means getting outhustled by one of hip-hop's best "Hustlers." Take it from acapella closer "Hope," Nas says it best when he says it like this: "Ain't got nuttin to do with old school, new school/Dirty South, West coast, East coast/this about us, this our thing/knahmsayin this came from the gut, from the blood, from the soul." That's why even though he's holding a black rose on the album cover, it's not a funeral you're attending on "Hip Hop is Dead," it's a wake. Nas has made a passionate album to reawaken your love of the art and if your heart isn't thumping in your chest by the end then it's not hip-hop that's dead, it's you.

Music Vibes: 10 of 10 Lyric Vibes: 10 of 10 TOTAL Vibes: 10 of 10

Originally posted: December 19, 2006
source: www.RapReviews.com
------------------------------------------------------------------



Opinions??


I want to say yes already.
 
#3
It's far from a classic.

The only thing I'll say that is classic, near classic, or will be a soon to be classic from 2006 is Doctor's Advocate.

Hopefully "Hip Hop Is Dead" won't be another average album that is given classic status like Black Album. The only thing classic about "Hip Hop Is Dead" is the album's title.
 
#4
a classic after it just leaked 3 weeks ago, to hail it classic status it must have some sort of LONGEVITY, not fucking 3 weeks, REPLAY VALUE is the key to classic albums, you mgiht bump the album now but in a month will you be bumping, you might not, so y'all won't be calling it classics then.

They are both being gassed up by there fans, Hip-Hop Is Dead was nice, but a classic, get the fuck outta here, Doctors Advocate was average.

Who the fuck wants to hear about Compton, Eazy-E on every fucking song, step up your content game up, were was the fucking creativity in the album, there was NONE.
 
#7
It's clear that everyone here has diferent opinions of what a classic should be.
To me Hip Hop Is Dead is a classic because if some outsider came to me and asked me to make a list of the albums that represent the true essence of hip hop, i would include it in that list without thinking twice as i would include Illmatic, Enter the 36 Chambers, Reflection Eternal, Me Against The World and other such great albums. Tell me of another album from the last two years that has so much originality and creativity, and that's what hip hop is all about!!!
 
#8
Bombsquad said:
It's far from a classic.

The only thing I'll say that is classic, near classic, or will be a soon to be classic from 2006 is Doctor's Advocate.

Hopefully "Hip Hop Is Dead" won't be another average album that is given classic status like Black Album. The only thing classic about "Hip Hop Is Dead" is the album's title.
If Hip Hop Is Dead isn't a classic there is NO WAY the doctors advocate could hold that title. I don't think either are classics but two good albums
 

linx

Well-Known Member
Staff member
#9
Nah, I don't think it's a classic personally. I think it's a great album though. It just didn't hit me like other classics have the first/second time I listened to them, ya know? Like Long Live The Kane, Strictly Business, Low End Theory, Illmatic, Only Built 4 Cuban Linx, etc. I don't think it has to be as good as other albums I consider classic though. I don't see the need to compare it to others like that, I just look at it on its own first.
 
#10
DUB CEE said:
If Hip Hop Is Dead isn't a classic there is NO WAY the doctors advocate could hold that title. I don't think either are classics but two good albums
Doctor's Advocate has more replay value than Hip Hop Is Dead. Ol English alone from DA has more replay value than the majority of "Hip Hop Is Dead".
 

ARon

Well-Known Member
#11
Some people are a joke. If it sounds good it sounds good, who gives a fuck who made it or when it was made. Opinions are starting to annoy me, its always, "its crap if this was 80 90 blah blah this would be shit, fuck rap nowadays its garbage blah blah blah." No you are garbage, you are unable to grow and are being left behind. I hate talkin like I'm all tight and shit but fuck, can we stop disregarding every album that comes out now cus we think the state of rap sucks. People act like nothing is good, its ridiculous.
 
#12
Bombsquad said:
Doctor's Advocate has more replay value than Hip Hop Is Dead. Ol English alone from DA has more replay value than the majority of "Hip Hop Is Dead".
Sorry but I have to disagree. I very rarely play the Game's album anymore but I just got Nas' album. If I wasn't so lazy to go downstairs and get my snoop cd out of the car i'd be listening to that more then both of those albums combined.
 
#14
Bombsquad said:
It's far from a classic.

The only thing I'll say that is classic, near classic, or will be a soon to be classic from 2006 is Doctor's Advocate.

Hopefully "Hip Hop Is Dead" won't be another average album that is given classic status like Black Album. The only thing classic about "Hip Hop Is Dead" is the album's title.
Dead on abou Black Album...so true. HHID is a great CD but its too early man gotta see who this LP influences/helps rap and its rappers
 
#16
Yes it is. Check the record, young ones. Do you think Game's 2nd record is going to be listenable in a few months with that constant name dropping he loves so much? I don't think so. Game doesn't spit lyrics that stand the test of time yet. His songs can be occaisionally catchy, but never classic necessarily. Take every single from "The Documentary." They were all successful commercially, but had no redeeming qualities besides their catchy construction. People have forgotten that record, and they'll forget his newest one too. In my opinion, each year has a classic record in hip-hop, and Mr. Jones has crafted 2006's masterpiece.
 
#18
People need to chill….

Everyone is discussing “what constitutes a classic” or “what they personally believe a classic is”. All of that is bullshit. When you are hearing a classic album, man, you just KNOW. There is no debate, no kicking up shyt and trying to find flaws. You just know, man.

As far as Hip Hop Is Dead is concerned, I would not categorize it as a classic. But, it is still WAY TOO EARLY to be able to tell; some albums develop well over time. Consider it this way though: can you picture yourself (along with most other members of the hip-hop community) anointing this record, within the next 12-36 months, among the greatest of all-time? Me neither.
 
#19
realBOSTON said:
People need to chill….

Everyone is discussing “what constitutes a classic” or “what they personally believe a classic is”. All of that is bullshit. When you are hearing a classic album, man, you just KNOW. There is no debate, no kicking up shyt and trying to find flaws. You just know, man.

As far as Hip Hop Is Dead is concerned, I would not categorize it as a classic. But, it is still WAY TOO EARLY to be able to tell; some albums develop well over time. Consider it this way though: can you picture yourself (along with most other members of the hip-hop community) anointing this record, within the next 12-36 months, among the greatest of all-time? Me neither.
Myself, yes, can't talk on everyone's behalf though!!
 
#20
Ive had the album in my whip all day, and it didnt leave my CD player once. This CD is one of the best in 2006 next to snoop imo. Game CD is already played out for me, like numerous other people stated the consistent song by song dr name dropping is boring to say the least. Nas's album is lyrically superior to games, whoever dont see this don't know the difference between hip hop and rap.
 

Latest posts

Donate

Any donations will be used to help pay for the site costs, and anything donated above will be donated to C-Dub's son on behalf of this community.

Members online

No members online now.
Top