Eminem Show - Top 10 album all time?

[malek_5]

I listened to this album recently after not hearing it in awhile, and it's just crazy. EVERY song, his flow is insane, it revolves around one topic (getting out of the spotlight), and the production is unfukwitable. You always hear about older albums being classics, but Eminem Show, IMO is right up there. Where would you place it compared to other classic albums?

 

[GhettoStar]

not even in the top 10, but MM lp has legit claim

 

[Pittsey]

It's not in my top 20. Maybe even 50.

 

[malek_5]

not even in the top 10, but MM lp has legit claim

That's what everybody says, but go song for song on both shits, Eminem show is all over MMLP. There's some mediocre songs on mmlp, like 'kim', 'marshall mathers', 'drug ballad', 'who knew'.... his flow doesn't touch what it does on Eminem Show. I mean, 'business', 'say goodbye to hollywood', 'sing for the moment', 'till i collapse' (maybe em's best song)...listen to his verse on 'when the music stops', he fucking kills that shit. and his own production is on a higher level

 

[one mc on dj]

That's what everybody says, but go song for song on both shits, Eminem show is all over MMLP. There's some mediocre songs on mmlp, like 'kim', 'marshall mathers', 'drug ballad', 'who knew'.... his flow doesn't touch what it does on Eminem Show. I mean, 'business', 'say goodbye to hollywood', 'sing for the moment', 'till i collapse' (maybe em's best song)...listen to his verse on 'when the music stops', he fucking kills that shit. and his own production is on a higher level

The eminem show has some mediocre songs too...

'say goodbye to hollywood', 'sing for the moment'
Soldier....that track with obie trice...superman

can't forget without me although it is a nice song...it annoys me that it;s a marketing trick..it doesnt bother me that much but if u gon take a critical look I say it its ok to mention...

 

[two187pac]

flow isnt everything

 

[Ay-G]

pft, that shit should stay somewhere below the 50s. hahaha top 10! please.

 

[Saaphir]

Eminem Show ain't even Em's best album...plus it's far from being a classic...Ever heard of Gangstarr's "Moment Of Truth"?
Top 10 album all time?BUHAHAHA!!!
I hope you're kidding,son!

 

[S O F I]

The eminem show has some mediocre songs too...

'say goodbye to hollywood', 'sing for the moment'
Soldier....that track with obie trice...superman

can't forget without me although it is a nice song...it annoys me that it;s a marketing trick..it doesnt bother me that much but if u gon take a critical look I say it its ok to mention...

I'm not agreeing with the thread starter on the album being in top ten, but to say that "Sing for the Moment" is a mediocre track, you just have to be a moron.

 

[one mc on dj]

I'm not agreeing with the thread starter on the album being in top ten, but to say that "Sing for the Moment" is a mediocre track, you just have to be a moron.

Whatever man....just don't call me a moron...

 

[Butt Rubber]

slim shady LP would make my top 5

eminem show wouldn't make my top 50

 

[Saaphir]

slim shady LP would make my top 5

eminem show wouldn't make my top 50

There is no way SS LP is in top 5 albums of all time.

 

[Cooper]

I listened to this album recently after not hearing it in awhile, and it's just crazy. EVERY song, his flow is insane, it revolves around one topic (getting out of the spotlight), and the production is unfukwitable. You always hear about older albums being classics, but Eminem Show, IMO is right up there. Where would you place it compared to other classic albums?

MMLP is much better IMO....kim & stan are nice concepts plus kill you, marshall mathers and the way i am are good tracks, along with MOST of the rest.....the d12 ones shit tho

 

[one mc on dj]

There is no way SS LP is in top 5 albums of all time.

I dunno..maybe its me but I think he said that LP could make into HIS top 5....

 

[Pittsey]

There is no way SS LP is in top 5 albums of all time.

It's in my top 5. At number 5.

But it's all about preference. I loved that album when it dropped. Played it for months. It captured how I felt at that time and it was funny.

 

[linx]

I really enjoy Em's albums, but none of them are top 10 imo.

 

[AmerikazMost]

MM LP > SS LP > Eminem Show > Encore

none of them are top ten, maybe not even top 20...mm lp is close

 

[Base_D]

The eminem show has no replay value. 1 listen is aight, but after that I get tired of it. so it could never be in my top 10/20. Only til i collapse is bumpable (if that's even a word)

 

[Little Skittle]

for anyone to say that eminem show isnt in the top 50 of all time is rediculous....its EASILY in the top 25...but top 10 might be pushin it

 

[Cooper]

easily top 25? no....