When does an Apple not become an Apple?

[Bender]

At what point ...

 

[AmerikazMost]

What the hell does that mean?

 

[Bender]

A philosophical riddle I got from a book. It means, You start off with an Apple before you eat it; It's an Apple before you eat it, but yet not after. So, at what point does it loose its appleness?

 

[AmerikazMost]

after all the fruit is gone?

 

[_carmi]

after its all eaten?

 

[Preach]

at what point does it loose its appleness?

lmao

 

[Bender]

after its all eaten?

But if its not an apple after you have eaten it, what have you just eaten?

 

[Bender]

Don't ask me I don't know the answer either.

 

[Cooper]

it doesnt lose its appleness, when eaten its still an apple

 

[Bender]

it doesnt lose its appleness, when eaten its still an apple

Ok, I can go with that.


So what comes out the other end? Certainly not an apple ...

I'm serious btw.

 

[Cooper]

obviously when eaten and digested, it then changes

 

[CoolWaterz]

this isnt a riddle, this is a scientific question asking at what point does an apple turn into human shit.

 

[Default MX]

^ Lmao!

 

[Preach]

^^
but the human body doesnt digest the whole apple in one . an apple consists of a trillion billion atoms and the apple is digested over a period of time. basically, it doesnt lose its appleness at one specific point, it loses its appleness over a period of time. technically, one could say that the apple is no longer an apple soon as the last cell has been split.

 

[CoolWaterz]

^^
but the human body doesnt digest the whole apple in one . an apple consists of a trillion billion atoms and the apple is digested over a period of time. basically, it doesnt lose its appleness at one specific point, it loses its appleness over a period of time. technically, one could say that the apple is no longer an apple soon as the last cell has been split.

yup- and then comes the doody.

 

[Preach]

^^
aye, as the rainy season on the rain forest.

 

[tupac004]

ummmm..... its an apple before you eat it, but an apple core when you are done. as far as im aware of, it never loses its envied applehood

 

[S O F I]

Who says an apple is an apple?

 

[LilTrigger]

Whats it supposed to be a strawberry?

 

[~live2tell~]

Am I missing a punchline here