Biscan?!?! Are you f'in crazy?? He was awesome for Liverpool! Of course the first few seasons he wasn't that great becasue the genius in Houllier played him as a Winger or as a CB... When Xabi Alonso was injured he was HUGE for Liverpool's success in the CL. And the fans in Liverpool reckognize that.
I'm not saying he was God (God here does not mean Robbie Fowler), but hell I could've named you a 100 other players who were worse than him (Brolin, Silenzi, Padovano, Boogers, Brian Pinas (huhuhuhu), Guivarc'h)
Smicer was OK.
The rest were shit huhu.
I'd add Milosevic there though.