I still don't agree. He's average. As is Reo Coker and Sidwell. As Cantona would say.... He's a water carrier.
Milner is above average. But a long way from world class. Downing is a decent premiership footballer. Young has the most natural talent at Villa. Gab could be world class if he lived up to his potential. Apart from your defence, which is very good. Although Brad will need replacing sooner, rather than later. I see lots of holes. I used to think Carew was a fantastic player, but his heart wasn't in it last season.
You need Central midfielders and a quality striker. Otherwise top 6 is your aim.
Get Barry back for 2.5m.