Similarities in Religion

[Jurhum]

That's something I find strange about religion. Do people really need the threat of being punished by a Supreme Being to make them respect others? I would have thought respect for others was a naturally and obviously positive idea, something (almost) everyone would aspire to.

It's more than just respecting others. It's a standard created by God which governs our daily interaction with all creation.

Goes back to debates in regard to the state of nature.. are we naturally peaceful or conflictual? Do we need a method of social control (arguably a purpose religion serves) to over-ride our natural instincts to disrespect others in the competitive, anarchic environment? I too would have thought it would be natural and obvious... or just common sense... that respect and tolerance would be a trait we are naturally endowed with (those that arent being an exception to the norm). Perhaps having a mind built on such principles is the real exception... (or at least the result of many years of social engineering).

Humankind are more inclined to evil than to good, naturally

 

[Amara]

Humankind are more inclined to evil than to good, naturally

That's debatable... I dont think there is a definitive answer.

 

[XIAN]

That's something I find strange about religion. Do people really need the threat of being punished by a Supreme Being to make them respect others? I would have thought respect for others was a naturally and obviously positive idea, something (almost) everyone would aspire to.

I don't think it's a "threat" so much. It's just that they are told by a religion that they are actually not alone and not unloved. They have a "supreme being" who loves them so much, and because of this, they feel the urge to try to give back that love through self-discipline and helping others.

For example in Tibet they were a warrior nation for centuries until Buddhism came and for the last few centuries they have been the world's most peaceful nation.

I would say that people (as a collective mostly) are not naturally inclined to be selfless and peaceful, but there are many among them who see the right way, and if they can lead, then they will lead the people to the way. Not everyone can be a messiah, they usually have to learn it from someone else.

~peace~