The G1 is the best phone I've ever owned, or seen for that matter. Nothing has or will have the longevity of this thing.
Good choice with the G2. I think it's the best thing out right now, better than the Nexus S as well.
Truth. G1 has had crazy longevity. Some of the Android dev guys recently said that any phone that runs Froyo well should run Gingerbread without any problems. So the fact that rooted G1's with the right kernels will be able to run full Gingerbread is just awesome. I remember a year ago people weren't even sure if the G1 would be able to run Eclair! And yeah, I'm feeling the G2 way more than the Nexus S overall.
Also, why is the G2 better than the Nexus S?
For me - QWERTY and the microSD slot are the main two features as both of those are high up on my priority list. I saw the NFC chip and front camera as the tradeoff with the Nexus S, but it'll be a couple years before anyone does anything really interesting with NFC anyway, and there's still no native video chat with Gingerbread so the G2 comes out on top in that respect. When you type as much as I do, not having a QWERTY is a serious compromise. And now that you can get 16GB microSD cards for like, $30... I just don't understand why they took it out in the Nexus S.
On top of that, I don't like the designs of Samsung phones. I think they're pretty ugly compared to HTC. The G2 looks classy with the titanium back panel and solid build quality.... Samsung's devices feel kinda cheap to me. The only one I like is the Epic 4G, but it's CDMA only......so useless to anyone outside of the US. The radio bands in the G2 work for 3G in the US and in the UK, which are the two places I'll obviously be using it the most. On top of all that, $330 for the G2 new on eBay VS $550 for the Nexus..... the Nexus has slightly better hardware, but not $220 better when I'd already feel like I'm compromising by not having a keyboard.
Engadget just did a preview of the LG Star, which is using a tegra2, it's stupid fast. CES 2011 is like a week into january, we're gonna see all kinds of new devices being shown. I'm waiting for those, even though I probably won't be able to buy them right away, I have patience though. I'm not going to buy a tech that is at the end of its life cycle, buying the nexus s or even the g2 is doing that
Yeah, I saw it. Kinda hard to judge just what it's capable of now since it's running Froyo and even Gingerbread isn't yet optimized for dual core devices. Gotta wait till Honeycomb for that. Nice looking hardware on the Star but WTF at that new LG UI they've got going on.... it looks like TouchWiz and I hate TouchWiz.
yeah everyone has different needs. If speed is what you're after then basically Galaxy S = Nexus S = ~G2.
Speed is comparable. Bear in mind with custom kernels people are already running G2's at 1.9GhZ. They're probably running the risk of it exploding lol but I reckon you could run it stable at 1.6GhZ. Not that there's anything on Android that needs it. I've yet to find a single app that doesn't run perfectly on my cousins HTC Desire which has the old 1GhZ Snapdragon..... and as we know, the Scorpion in the G2 is a superior processor.
So yeah, I'm one of these people who think that Desire Z was a step back from the original desire because of inferior display and bigger size. The new Sense UI is the most appealing thing to me, which the G2 doesn't have.
I fucking DESPISE Sense UI with a passion. I had to use it when I was flashing custom ROM's all the time on the HTC Hero that one of my cousins has. It's horrible, laggy in places due to being poorly written, a memory hog, convoluted, annoying, and they've replaced good parts of stock Android with inferior replacements. Have you ever used "People" which is the Sense contacts app? It's fucking
terrible. My cousin that has the HTC Desire specifically asked for a stock ROM to get rid of Sense so I put Cyanogen on there and he much prefers it.
Also, I think that the keyboard mechanism on Desire Z is terrible and really I'm not alone in this.
You know what, I've read a few people saying this but the fact remains that most of them haven't used it themselves. I demo'd a Desire Z at HTC's London launch party and it's really not that bad.... I prefer the keyboard layout of the G1 but I know I'll get used to the G2 layout really quickly. Also, it has shortcut buttons on the keyboard that you can map to launch any app or service which is awesome, and it has a "www./.com" button which is pretty self explanatory and obviously handy.
If it comes to the Nexus S and Galaxy S the Super Amoled screen is a killer feature that pwns anything else as far as my needs are concerned. It could have a 500mhz processor and I would still buy it if I wanted to replace my phone. I just really dislike TouchWiz and I'm not interested to pay that much for a phone in the first place so go figure :|
Screen quality is probably quite literally the lowest priority on my list. I really don't see a great deal of difference. If a phone had all the things I wanted and also happened to have a SAMOLED, obviously I wouldn't complain, but there isn't a phone out there that fits that description other than the US-only Epic 4G. It's not like I plan to watch movies on my phone LOL. I have a HDTV and a laptop that are better suited for that task.
I could have waited longer and seen how things go in Q1 and Q2, but I need a new phone right now, I just got my quarterly royalties statement for songwriting which put a nice chunk into my account, so I figured why wait, and right now the G2 ticks all of the boxes, which even the Nexus S doesn't.
Something else I discovered through all of this..... I just got this G2 on eBay US for £200 UK, and somebody just sold a sim-unlocked G2 on eBay UK for just under £400. I'm thinking maybe I'll buy a couple more, SIM-unlock them myself and flip 'em to make a few extra bucks. If people are willing to pay that much then I may as well
The G2 devs on XDA built SIM-unlocking into the same process as rooting, so you don't even need to go out of your way to SIM unlock like you do with some devices.