^^ well...on paper you do....your pitching is really your weak spot..
see, i see your roster like this (potentially) for the playoffs and no sooner..
C-Posada
1B-Giambi
2B-Cano
3B Gay-Rod
SS Jeter
OF-Damon
Matsui
Abreu
DH-Sheff-ster
and as much as i love melky, i feel if he's coming off the bench later on in the game, or sheff needs to rest that wrist of his, melky can just come out and DH or play OF....just melky alone adds so much depth to your bench...
the pitching is still a scary issue... farns is really just...weird...being a former cub, i def. know about that.... proctors straight...meyers is straight....randy is just out of it...where the hell is pavano? wright's coming along fine...wang gets the win...moose is def. the ace....but if you stack em up against a couple other possible playoff teams...for fuck's sake, the white sox....i dont think the pitching can hold up...garland is coming around...getting runs back from him iwll be hard..contreras always does well against the yanks....so..i dunno...
then lets say the twins make it...johan, and carlos silva are tough fuckers...im not so sure about liriano when he comes back, but what if he comes back strong?? in the division series, its that could be the ingredients to a sweep...