Would you vote for McGwire*?

[Dogmatic187]

Mark McGwire* is on the ballot for next years Hall of Fame selections, and it simple. If you had a vote would you vote for him?

Here are his career numbers:

Games
1,874
AB
6,187
R
1,167
H
1,626
2B
252
3B
6
HR
583
GS
14
RBI
1,414
BB
1,317
IBB
150
SO
1,596
SH
3
HSP
78
HBP
75
GIDP
147
AVG
.263
OBP
.394
SLG
.588

 

[Butt Rubber]

helllllll no

talk about one dimensional players

 

[AmerikazMost]

If it wasn't for the power numbers he got with the 'roids, I don't think he'd even be considered.

So hells no. If they vote him in after everything that's come out, after the ridiculous front he put on in front of Congress, it would tarnish the integrity of the Hall.

 

[yak pac fatal]

no, never, hes a cheater

 

[Get In The Van I Have Candy]

I would not vote for McGwire* But I do give him credit for reviving baseball along with Sosa*.

 

[xxx]

sure, hes famous for baseball. Its not the baseball hall of greatness and integrity.

 

[tennis_dog]

well, being a cubs fan, i dunno about sosa...i doubt he doped, but then again, i havent really given two shits about him since he left... so i havent been up to date with the latest steroid news and accusations...

either way, i think mcgwire should just be happy for his short lived fame.....he should, in no way, expect to be elected into the hall.... he doesnt belong there.... what good did he do?? he didnt even have an average...for him, it was all about the homers...what was sosa's career avg? wasnt much better, but he hasnt really been brought to trial, and he really hasnt been accused of steroids, at least not as much as giambi, bonds, raffy and big mac.... hell, i think tejada took more of a hit than sammy did, after he was rumored to have been the one using them with the A's...