Who was the best pound-for-pound boxer?

[SicC]

I got this list off of msn.com. I was very disappointed that Roy Jones Jr. was not included.

So lets see what this site thinks.

 

[DEA]

I voted for Rocky Marciano, cause he is the only Heavyweight Champ to go undefeated.

 

[SicC]

LOL ^^^ Such a poor reason, the guy fought bums, and would have lost sooner rather than later if not for what happened to him.

pz

 

[dea1983]

Nice pic sicC , I'm guessing which way your vote went lol :thumb:

For me Sugar Ray Robinson.

A boxer going undefeated has little or no bearing on p4p, if it did then fighters such as Sven Ottke would be there also.

 

[stefanwzyga]

For me ray robinson and ali stand shoulder to shoulder as the greatest pound for pound fighters. I picked robinson in the vote though.

Dont understand why mike tysons in the list, thats a joke. Also think henry armstrong should be on the list.

DEA Rocky never fought any strong young black contenders, he fought walcott/charles/louis/moore/ when they were in there mid to late thirties.

 

[SicC]

well im still baffled as to why roy jones jr was not on the list, i rank him number two behind ali personally. Ya the whole mike tyson on the list was more amusing than anything.

pz

 

[stefanwzyga]

I think the problem with roy is that he was a great fighter but never in a great fight. It shouldnt take away from the fact that he was pound for pound one of the greatest.